The UK’s broadcasting watchdog, Ofcom, has unveiled the most controversial TV moments of 2024, highlighting what sparked outrage among viewers. With over 60,000 complaints filed, the list includes fiery debates, reality TV drama, and uncomfortable storylines from shows like Good Morning Britain, Love Island, Big Brother, and Emmerdale. While most complaints didn’t lead to rule violations, a handful of moments stood out. Here’s a rundown of the year’s most talked-about TV moments.
10. Big Brother and the Watermelon Controversy
Complaints: 500+
In October, Big Brother housemate Ali Bromley wore a T-shirt featuring a watermelon, a symbol reportedly linked to anti-Israel sentiment. Ofcom concluded the image’s limited visibility and duration did not warrant further investigation, emphasizing personal expression rights.
9. Nut Allergies on This Morning
Complaints: 600+
Nick Ferrari sparked outrage in May by dismissing nut allergies, saying, “If you don’t like peanuts, don’t get on the plane.” Despite the backlash, Ofcom noted Ferrari’s reputation for provocative opinions and an on-air apology the next day.
8. Susanna Reid vs. Nigel Farage
Complaints: 700+
A heated Good Morning Britain interview with Nigel Farage saw Susanna Reid interrupting him repeatedly. Ofcom stated that the robust questioning aligned with audience expectations, and Farage was given ample opportunity to voice his opinions.
7. Sunak vs. Starmer Debate
Complaints: Various Issues
The ITV debate between Rishi Sunak and Keir Starmer attracted numerous complaints ahead of the General Election. Ofcom concluded both candidates had equal opportunities to address policy questions and challenge each other’s claims.
6. Big Brother’s Sarah Griffiths Sparks Outrage
Complaints: 747
Sarah Griffiths received backlash for a controversial play on words, twisting Rishi Sunak’s slogan “Stop the boats” into “Stop the gloats”. While viewers raised concerns, Ofcom noted her apology and Big Brother’s prompt response to address the remarks.
5. Emmerdale: Tom King’s Dog Abuse Scene
Complaints: Significant
Episodes aired in late May depicting Tom King injecting Belle’s dog, Piper, as part of a coercive control storyline. Ofcom noted the lack of graphic detail and the context within the soap’s tradition of tackling challenging themes.
4. XL Bully Debate on Good Morning Britain
Complaints: 1,777
A debate on XL bully dogs between Mike Parry and Kay Taiwo escalated into a heated exchange. Parry’s remarks about euthanizing dangerous dogs upset viewers, but Ofcom highlighted the balanced counterpoints made by Taiwo during the segment.
3. Joey Essex on Love Island
Complaints: 1,832
Joey Essex’s dramatic and confrontational behavior stirred tension in the villa, particularly involving Mimii and Ayo’s relationship. Ofcom ruled that the show did not glamorize negative behavior and provided opportunities for resolution.
2. Ed Balls Interviews His Wife on Good Morning Britain
Complaints: High Volume
The unusual moment when Ed Balls interviewed his wife, Home Secretary Yvette Cooper, during an August episode of Good Morning Britain led to widespread complaints. Viewers found the segment awkward and potentially biased.
1. Big Brother Tops the List with Watermelon Controversy
The most complained-about moment of 2024 involved Ali Bromley’s T-shirt incident, garnering over 500 complaints. While controversial, Ofcom ruled the imagery did not breach guidelines, citing limited prominence and duration.
From political debates to reality TV drama, 2024 was a year of strong opinions and heated reactions in British television. Ofcom’s rulings showcase the delicate balance between audience expectations and broadcasters’ responsibilities to tackle sensitive issues.
