Season 3 of The Ultimatum: Marry or Move On concluded with a dramatic December 18, 2024 reunion episode. The reunion brought unresolved tensions and emotional confrontations to the forefront, including a fiery exchange between Aria and Caleb. Fans were left divided as Aria confronted Caleb about his alleged Instagram “lurking,” accusing him of insincerity in his relationship with Mariah.
Aria and Caleb’s Trial Marriage Journey
During the experiment, Aria and Caleb were trial marriage partners, leaving their original connections—Mariah and Scotty—behind. Initially, the two found comfort in each other’s company, but their emotional connection did not align. While Aria believed they shared a bond, Caleb viewed their relationship differently, leading to their eventual separation. Caleb later reconciled with Mariah, and the couple got engaged, planning a wedding for the summer of 2026.
The Instagram Drama: Aria Confronts Caleb
At the reunion, Aria accused Caleb of liking her Instagram Stories and blocking and unblocking her on the platform. She called his engagement to Mariah “fake” and criticized him for lurking on her page after his proposal. Caleb attempted to deflect by saying he also liked posts from Zaina, but Aria remained unconvinced.
Mariah, visibly taken aback, responded: “The blocking-not blocking, watching her Stories—that is news to me, first and foremost.” The revelations sparked a tense exchange, with Mariah urging Caleb to be honest about his actions and their implications for their relationship.
Fan Reactions: Divided Opinions on Aria and Caleb
Fans of the show took to X (formerly Twitter) to share their thoughts, with opinions split between Aria and Caleb.
Criticism of Aria: “Let It Go”
Many viewers felt Aria’s actions were driven by unresolved feelings for Caleb, with comments such as:
- “Aria had unrequited feelings for Caleb and tried to lash out. Girl, he wasn’t into you on that level. Let it go.”
- “Aria wants to ruin Mariah and Caleb’s relationship so bad. Girl, he didn’t choose you. Get over it.”
- “Aria’s grudge against Caleb for not choosing her is misplaced. Sorry, but he had a stronger connection with Mariah.”
Some fans labeled Aria’s behavior as vindictive, accusing her of attempting to disrupt Caleb and Mariah’s engagement out of bitterness.
Criticism of Caleb: “Take Accountability”
Others criticized Caleb for his lack of transparency, particularly for liking Aria’s posts without informing Mariah. Fans wrote:
- “Caleb out here watching and liking Aria’s IG Stories as an engaged man… admit you liked her.”
- “Even Caleb admitted there was an emotional connection with Aria. People said he was just being nice, but clearly, there was more.”
Mariah’s Reaction: “News to Me”
Mariah’s composed yet emotional response stood out during the heated exchange. She admitted that learning about Caleb’s behavior was difficult and expressed frustration at the contrasting feedback she received from both Caleb and Aria about their trial marriage. Her candor and calls for transparency resonated with fans, earning her support for how she handled the confrontation.
Scotty Weighs In: Calls for Accountability
Another cast member Scotty joined the conversation and urged Caleb to acknowledge the emotional connection he shared with Aria. He noted that Mariah needed validation of her feelings and called on Caleb to take responsibility for his actions. Caleb eventually admitted:
“I was trying to convince myself, but even watching it back, there was an emotional connection. I should’ve been more transparent.”
What’s Next for Caleb and Mariah?
As Caleb and Mariah engage, questions remain about their ability to overcome these revelations. The reunion showcased the complexities of navigating relationships formed under unique circumstances, leaving fans eager to see how the couple’s story unfolds.
Stream Now on Netflix
Season 3 of The Ultimatum: Marry or Move On is available to stream exclusively on Netflix. Whether you’re here for the love stories, the drama, or the heartfelt moments, this season delivers it all.
